CW: domestic violence, sexual assault.
If you or anyone you care about needs help, call 800.799.SAFE (7233) or text START to 88788 — the National Domestic Violence Hotline. Free, confidential, and available 24/7, or chat at thehotline.org.
Dear Mom,
Your court-appointed guardian called today with an update. She mentioned you have a boyfriend. I have heard that assisted living communities are the dating apps for octogenarians, so I’m not surprised. But she says this is different, that you’re in love. That your boyfriend’s family includes you in their gatherings. She says you’re very happy.
I’m glad. You’ve always deserved this, a life without Dad. Days free from violence, retribution, control. An existence unencumbered by the ever-present threat of beatings and marital rape. Your blind and unconditional loyalty to him has earned you this respite, these last five or ten years of peace. Enjoy yourself. Revel in feeling transported back to high school, when love was novel and overwhelming, giddy and urgent, more essential than air. Like I said, you’ve always deserved this.
But then, so did I. So did we.
I wish I could stop myself from wondering, why now? Why not after he grabbed you by the throat and wouldn’t let go until we wrapped our arms around his neck and pulled him away, dragging him back with the collective weight of our four bodies? Or when we screamed stop, stop, please stop as he slammed you against the clapboard walls of the cottage on the lake? My sisters and I threw ourselves on top of him that night, also, all while praying the screams had not been carried over the water to the close-by neighbors. You see, even that young, we knew we had two inescapable responsibilities: to keep you safe, and to keep forgiving him. This marriage is the most important part of our family, you told us many times. Without it, there is nothing.
Why did you not go to the police after your second broken neck? Or after he poured vodka down your throat until you were unconscious, then propped you up like a doll, naked and splay legged, to take zoomed-in photos of your vagina? Those were the photos your youngest daughter found when she was sixteen, on the top shelf of your closet in a box tucked beside Dad’s shoe shine kit. That day, she said, was one of the worst: I went to school and just looked around at all the people, thinking they hadn’t seen what I had seen. That I was not like them anymore.
Do you remember the time I threw the chair down the stairs to shock him out of a rage? I can still see it, my sister’s white desk chair in my hands, then hurling through the air, then crashing through the front door. Do you remember what he did? He looked up at me, standing at the top of the staircase, with fear in his eyes. He climbed the steps slowly, his trembling finger pointing at me. Remember how he always pointed his finger in our faces when he was seconds away from losing control? Just like that. But instead of running away, I descended the stairs toward him, toward his quivering jowls, purple with fury. I pointed my finger right back. I said, If you touch her again, I’m going to kill you. Do you remember how he backed down, turned and walked away from me?
The door was open then, after the chair broke through, and you were only a few steps away. You and your children were only a few steps away from the outside, from the other side.
I waited a long time that night, alone in my bedroom, for you to step inside and say a few words, but you never came. The next morning, we ate breakfast together before school, like we always did.
Why, when we were grown with homes purchased to also fit you, did you refuse to leave? Come live with us, Mom, we said. I’ll get in my car right now and be there in nine hours. Please let me. Then you’d laugh in that light, tinkling way you have and say, I’ll never leave your father. Never.
But you did leave, didn’t you? There really was a last straw, wasn’t there? When his eighty-two-year-old hands gripped your eighty-year-old throat for the final time, that was your breaking point. After you reported him to the church pastor and she called the police, after he was arrested and taken to jail and you were finally alone in that house of horrors, and after you told the social worker the sordid tale of your marriage, she asked you the same question. Why now? Because I just got sick of it, you said.
What if you had gotten sick of it thirty, forty, fifty years earlier? What if you had told a good friend that you needed a place for us to stay until we could find another house? What if you told the banker you needed to open a separate account and use it to rent an apartment? There was plenty of money. What if you had called a therapist, or joined a women’s support group to help you siphon off enough strength to leave?
I wish you could have found the will earlier, before alcohol became your favorite companion, before bitterness forced your smile lines downward. Maybe we could have seen Dad on Wednesdays and weekends, leaving just enough space for him to love us, but not enough space for him to hurt us. Maybe then you could have been thirty, forty or fifty years old and in teenage love again, and I could have been ten, twenty or thirty when I watched my dear mom emancipate herself. Maybe I could have been able to say, My mom is really something. Maybe we could have skipped the last two years of Dad in jail and you slowly fading into a reality that exists only in your mind. Maybe we would have been capable of caring for you for just a few years more, rather than surrendering your welfare to a stranger.
I’m happy you’re happy, Mom. I’m so glad you found love. I have always wanted more for you, just as I always wanted more for me, the little girl I was, the girl who wanted to be both loved and safe. The girl who wasn’t forced to choose one over the other.
Also, the guardian said you had a suspicious mole removed and are waiting for the results of a biopsy; nothing too serious.
Love, Your Daughter
******
***
The ManifestStation publishes content on various social media platforms many have sworn off. We do so for one reason: our understanding of the power of words. Our content is about what it means to be human, to be flawed, to be empathetic. In refusing to silence our writers on any platform, we also refuse to give in to those who would create an echo chamber of division, derision, and hate. Continue to follow us where you feel most comfortable, and we will continue to put the writing we believe in into the world.
***
Write for your Life with The Craft School
CRAFT SCHOOL is a vibrant community for writers led by Jeannine Ouellette, Emily Rapp Black, and Gina Frangello—three established writers with extensive teaching experience. They believe, and we agree, that when a community is both safe and rigorous, writers and their work flourish.
***
Inaction is not an option,
Silence is not a response
See our Resources and Readings
